Status
Not open for further replies.

linebaugh

Well-known member
Not that vim was even intending to contribute the conversation, but hardcore/punk/metal adjacent stuff feels like cheating with regards to good modern rock music. 'rock' feels a misnomer.
 

luka

Well-known member
does that describe you mvuent? no, it doesn't. you're not a dude and there's no shame in it. that's my definition of dude and im not having any arguments about it.
 

padraig (u.s.)

a monkey that will go ape
but hardcore/punk/metal adjacent stuff feels like cheating with regards to good modern rock music. 'rock' feels a misnomer.
yeah this is why I excluded them

the world of extreme guitars - grindcore, powerviolence, black and death metal and all variants thereof - being world unto itself

albeit with occasional crossover into the world of "rock music"
 

vimothy

yurp
yeah this is why I excluded them

the world of extreme guitars - grindcore, powerviolence, black and death metal and all variants thereof - being world unto itself

albeit with occasional crossover into the world of "rock music"
wait so what's the tldr for this thread?
 

padraig (u.s.)

a monkey that will go ape
wait so what's the tldr for this thread?
one of the new guys posted some hella generic 10th-gen NYC indie rock biz

luke etc gave him shit for it, there was some polemica, luke denounced rock music for the 1000th time

another new guy asked if dissensus liked any "modern rock acts"

which to me implies certain sonic parameters and probably a certain level of popularity

i.e. noise rock biz probably in, powerviolence no. not that you can't post whatever, just in response to his specific question.
 

mvuent

Void Dweller
does that describe you mvuent? no, it doesn't. you're not a dude and there's no shame in it. that's my definition of dude and im not having any arguments about it.
all very true. tho i do have the problem that people irl often mistake my being very introverted for being serious / uptight, not someone you can lower your guard around, etc. anyways that’s info suited for dannyl's therapy couch not choon of the day…


video was filmed in a Liminal Space
 

padraig (u.s.)

a monkey that will go ape
theyre rock lineage surely, or does it have to be indie specifically?
well everything's rock lineage

but ca. 79-87ish guitar music splits off into a separate world with its own lineage, like the cadet branch of a royal dynasty

(that's from the birth of hardcore thru grindcore, death metal, black metal fully established as codified things unto themselves)

there are numerous gray areas, of course

post-hardcore in general probably qualifies as "rock music" as it puts back in much of what hardcore stripped out of rock music
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top