just realized why do I dislike some of the hyperpop newschool stuff so much.
the sound design might be good but it simply does not make sense.
ie why in the fuck is this giant morphing blob opening a can of soda now?
i think this is really the disconnect with me and a lot of my peers. i've definitely spoken against 'sound design for its own sake' vis a vis ~deconstructed club~ on here before.
the older microhouse/-adjacent stuff third was posting feels more detail oriented, like smaller discrete objects in a dance, and less of a kind of sweep across the stereo field, or a crunch or a crash that takes up the entire soundspace that you hear in emily glass or chino amobi (two 'deconstructed' producers im actually quite fond of).
there's also a difference of emotional territory, that these two (hypothetical) schools of sound design satisfy different but not disconnected urges. one (deconstructed club) likened to sound design in high-budget film and the other (microhouse/glitch/breakbeat-mutations) to ... ?
the sophie quote shiels posted reminds me of an electroacoustic composer who said much the same, that the pop music of the future for them would have been compositions that simply modulate a drone. that take one note/chord on a synthesiser and the play of parameters -is- the progression of the composition. and that has been realised in our time.
Definitely, the treble range allows it to be so malleable, like middle eastern hand drums, darbukas etc. More bassier breaks don't nearly cut up as well as much, it almost demands that you make your tunes techy. Amen tunes go better with the soulful vibe of 94-95.
But if we go back to 93, hear the break in this, and it almost demands it to be techno-y
this holds true for my experience of trying to avoid the amen break because it's 'too easy' to make something passably good with it. you can't be as loose with say al green's 'i'm glad your mine' and have it sound satisfying the way you can kind of shithouse the amen break. where by the time you've made a different break sound good what you've made is no longer recognisable as any sort of breakbeat, you may as well have used a drum machine or pre-cut samples
giving all the tunes posted here a cursory listen (on laptop speakers!) as i add them to the rolling Homies Music playlist and will comment on them when they're all in there and i give em a second listen (sometime in the next ~48 hours)