N
nomadologist
Guest
That's really a nice sentiment. I'm very aware of the causes of their concerns. The history of American public discourse on racism, especially w/r/t popular music, is so incredibly complicated, though, that positive lyrics are by no means some sort of definitive word on the state of public policy and institutionalized racism.
People in America have been striving to put this sort of thing into perspective for a very long time. It's always on our minds, it's always at the forefront of our politics, it's always right there when something tense happens among different cultural or ethnic minorities here.
Public Enemy is hardly unproblematic to cite when it comes to racism, though, unfortunately: specifically when it comes to Prof. Griff, who's been accused of making anti-Semitic remarks more than once.
Some people would argue that as hip-hop lyrics became more sensationalized and shocking, public awareness of inner city violence and the seriousness of problems like drugs and gangs was raised, which had a net effect that was positive in terms of educating people who would otherwise be sheltered from the harsh realities about the fact that problems still exist for black/latino/inner city impoverished Americans.
(and I never said anything about lyrics making dealers out of anyone, either)
People in America have been striving to put this sort of thing into perspective for a very long time. It's always on our minds, it's always at the forefront of our politics, it's always right there when something tense happens among different cultural or ethnic minorities here.
Public Enemy is hardly unproblematic to cite when it comes to racism, though, unfortunately: specifically when it comes to Prof. Griff, who's been accused of making anti-Semitic remarks more than once.
Some people would argue that as hip-hop lyrics became more sensationalized and shocking, public awareness of inner city violence and the seriousness of problems like drugs and gangs was raised, which had a net effect that was positive in terms of educating people who would otherwise be sheltered from the harsh realities about the fact that problems still exist for black/latino/inner city impoverished Americans.
(and I never said anything about lyrics making dealers out of anyone, either)