think its funny how Kode 9 seems to be trying to push away / deny the house element though
4x4 ≠ rigid in my opinion. also (obviously) house is much more than 4x4
dunno, i can't speak for the man, and he is (to understate it!) a pretty deep guy, so i shouldn't make such assumptions about his opinion. it just seemed a bit weird in that interview how he said that this stuff is basically grime + soca
that's exactly what alot of the emerging stuff made by ex grime producers sounds like tho, grime had that for a while too less explicitly, albeit without the ground-crushing heaviness and speed of soca though, however from what i hear, most soca nowdays has a fucking massive steppers style kick to it though in all fairness.
i dunno, more or less everything i hear from the scene (except maybe Little Silver and JME) has a very distincive house flavour, or at least something which clearly ties it to that lineage. to posit it as a complete break i think is misjudged. whether he was doing that or not im not sure. also i think rnb is a key influence for a few producers, and that there is some precedent in dancehall production
i was also thinking back about this 4x4 (as in 4 to the floor) = 'rigid' thing a while back, and was thinking that a lot of this broken uk stuff is actually extremely rigid and angular (as was grime), its just not as 'straight' or unbroken. wheras say old-school 4x4 garage was ridiculously swung, much less rigid in a sense (in the way that i understand the word). whats wrong with rigidity anyhow?... even if funk is the only thing you value, rigid can be as funky as anything else. i find rules like that (4x4 = rigid = boring) strange things
see i disagree, but its just a matter of semantics essentially, 'rigidity' to me is how tight a rhythm is to a straight rhythmic grid, not how much it centres on a regular kick (although obviously there's overlap)
but this isn't really worth discussing i don't think, cos its just semantics.
on the house thing, i guess i just don't want to see critics / commentators sever unfashionable heritage and for it to get railroaded into a compound of established styles, which remove what made it exciting again in the first place. i would like to see house remain in its blood but in new (probably borderline unrecognisable) incarnations... this is already happening with some producers i think
For me funky house, the sort of bongo heavy 4 4 tasteful world house thing, that's been around for like 15 years coming out of strictly rhythm and masters at work, regardless of developments from all over the world during that time, has managed to stay incredibly dull, despite being ubiquitous, so for some developments to upset the apple cart from the inside is really welcome.